So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Discuss everything related to Trackmania 2.

Moderator: English Moderator

osen
Posts: 7
Joined: 16 Aug 2011, 18:04

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by osen »

ionian wrote:
osen wrote:I don't get this argument. Gran Turismo 5 has over a thousand cars, 200 of them "Premium" with a ridiculous amount of detail, all with different handling characteristics. And 26 different locations. And it's a sim game with scanned tracks and ridiculously more advanced physics. TM2:Canyon is ONE car, ONE location, insanly simple physics in comparison and user generated tracks. I don't se how 7 cars and 7 locations could cost €140, that's all.

It's not about not having the money. It's about not wanting to pay €140 for something that should, in comparison to other games, be one normaly priced game.

Don't take me wrong. I love Trackmania and I hope TM2 is awesome. But I can't see how they could justify a price of €20 per environment. I mean, I can understand the price for the first environment, it's a new graphics and physics engine I pressume, that takes a lot of work, but the next enironments will use the same engine I pressume, so they should cost like a DLC car/track in Forza or something.
I could go into the arguments of why TM is not Gran Turismo, and comparing the two is like comparing apples and oranges; I could explain that TDU2 and Just Casue 2 use the same engine, but you wouldn't have paid a cheaper price for one of them; I could explain that it is not going to cost €140 euros as this is not TMUF - but the truth is it doesn't matter. You are free to choose to not buy the game if you feel it represents bad value for money. This is your right as a consumer. Just remember that whilst you are sat at home outraged at the price of the game, the majority of this forum will be enjoying map-making, drifting, and general racing goodness :yes:
:D

Of course it's not Gran Turismo, I never stated that, it was the guy I quoted that tried to imply that GT only has one enivronment, which is absurd. And it's a sim racing game, I wouldn't even call Trackmania an arcade racing game, it's something else. I don't believe it will cost €140 either.

Of course I'm free to choose not to buy the game, but that's not what this is about! Maybe I don't make myself clear. (I'm probably going to buy the equivalent of Stadium, if it's a standalone game, or Canyon and Stadium if it isn't, if you want to know ;) I didn't care much for other than Stadium in TM1) And I'm sure many would buy the game anyway, even if it was priced at that level. But I question if enough will, I'm just trying to understand the reasoning behind it, if it indeed would be like that. Obviously game developers seek to extract the maximum amount of money from their games and if they can charge €140 for a game and it's the most profitable of course they will, nothing strange about that, I'm just wondering if that is indeed the case. But who am I to question?

My initial question if there was any info about how much the environments will cost each and if they will be standalone games or not, this is a bit off topic LOL. I'm not outraged at all, I couldn't care less to be honest. I just want a new Nations and I will gladly pay €20 for it, but that's not the point. And I hope I will enjoy TM2 a lot, I can't wait for it, I still love Nations to this day.
ionian
Posts: 280
Joined: 15 Jun 2010, 11:43
Location: UK
Contact:

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by ionian »

No worries Ossen, I understand your point. I was lucky to be one of those people who loved all 7 environments in TMU, but i know that loads of people had a favourite (stadium being very popular). The thing is, you won't know what you like until you try it - and for £20/€20 its surely worth a try... it doesn't mean you have to buy the next one, or the one after that.

I really object to the pricing model of a lot of games these days, but Nadeo gave me soooo much value in their previous releases that I am happy to trust them in a way I wouldn't with other developers.
Image | dr.ionianá…• | Digital Racers Forum
osen
Posts: 7
Joined: 16 Aug 2011, 18:04

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by osen »

Hylis wrote:
osen wrote:Don't take me wrong. I love Trackmania and I hope TM2 is awesome. But I can't see how they could justify a price of €20 per environment. I mean, I can understand the price for the first environment, it's a new graphics and physics engine I pressume, that takes a lot of work, but the next enironments will use the same engine I pressume, so they should cost like a DLC car/track in Forza or something.
Even some games are made by one man and have great success and games made by many not worth it. Like Balmung said, it is either you enjoy it or not. I know that we have worked ten times more on one environment than on the one before, I know that there is a bigger system behind than ever and I know that enabling the power of the players to be in the game is great. But you just have to buy the first one and not the others, this is as simple as that if you find it not worth. I think it will, but I don't want to sell you to this now, because I still have to do the job after.

We delivered engine and online updates through years and an environment and technology that you can not compare. I don't say it is better, but go look for the track editor of GT or I even spoke with the Forza creative director, telling him the light is nice in its game, and he told me he was impressed by our track editor. We took a different path for development. Please do not compare the number of cars in Gran Turismo to our game or we will all end with Gran Turismo games. GT is great, but you are on the ManiaPlanet/TrackMania forums, and I think it is something else. The average time of play of TMU is at 70 hours and last time regular players bought something was in 2006, and you will find many still playing it.
Thank you for the answer and insight :) And well said, of course it's about enjoyment. To make a relativley simple game that many will enjoy and pay for is of course an accomplishment and I personally would take such a game over a game with no enjoyment and lot's of content any day. I'm just questioning the market strategy. But as I said, who am I to question it? I'm just interested. I'm wondering if enough people will buy all the parts of the game at that price, especially if there is going to be a combined pack later with much reduced price (I believe TMUF was priced around "normal" games?).

Of course there is no track editor in a sim racing game, those players want real tracks, that's the point of a sim. As you say, TM it's a completly different type of game. I don't see why I can't compare the number of cars though. I was comparing the raw work that has gone into the games, in comparison to price. But of course there are many other factors, it may be stupid to compare like that, but I'm having a hard time seeing people pay the same for, let's say, Minecraft and Battlefield 3, even if the enjoyment would be the same. In the end, what matters for a game developer is to extract as much money as possible, in other words get as many players as possible. If Nadeo can do that with this pricing, good for them. I just don't see it, but I'm no marketing consultant :D
zarexz

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by zarexz »

I must really have a completely different perception of the value of money I guess. 20 bucks is even less then peanuts. For me, a small two hours work. For the avarage smoker about 3 days worth of smoking. A paperboy could earn that in a week.... About 4 weeks saving avarage allowens? Doing the dishes for your parrents? Wash your uncle's car? C'mon guys, get over it! :teub:
User avatar
weerwolf
Posts: 603
Joined: 15 Jun 2010, 21:21
Location: Wijchen, Netherlands
Contact:

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by weerwolf »

PLZZZ tell me that i can download the dedicated beta aswell?
If it does, ill stay up until 0.00 hrs and......
get very little sleep :P

Im ready ;)
User avatar
Xymph
Posts: 1399
Joined: 15 Jun 2010, 20:35
Contact:

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by Xymph »

weerwolf wrote:tell me that i can download the dedicated beta aswell?
Seeing how Nadeo has launched over 150* servers to host this multiplayer beta, that seems unlikely, but it hasn't been confirmed either way yet.
Besides, the original group of beta testers is also hosting a variety of servers.

*Edit: That may have been a server browser glitch, now I'm seeing 30+ servers.
Last edited by Xymph on 16 Aug 2011, 22:05, edited 1 time in total.
Developer of XASECO for TMF/TMN ESWC & XASECO2 for TM²: see XAseco.org
Find your way around the Mania community from the TMN ESWC hub, TMF hub, TM² hub, and SM hub
osen
Posts: 7
Joined: 16 Aug 2011, 18:04

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by osen »

ionian wrote:No worries Ossen, I understand your point. I was lucky to be one of those people who loved all 7 environments in TMU, but i know that loads of people had a favourite (stadium being very popular). The thing is, you won't know what you like until you try it - and for £20/€20 its surely worth a try... it doesn't mean you have to buy the next one, or the one after that.

I really object to the pricing model of a lot of games these days, but Nadeo gave me soooo much value in their previous releases that I am happy to trust them in a way I wouldn't with other developers.
Hehe :D You're right, I don't know what it's like. And as I said, I will gladly pay €20 for Canyon, and €20 more for the equivalent of Stadium. But more than that? No, not for me. I would react in the same way if another game was chopped up and released in parts, I would wonder about the marketing strategy if Battlefield 3 was released for €140 aswell. But what I'm going to do doesn't really matter. I would probably buy a GT5 release with just one car and Nordschleife for €20 as well :D For me, it's worth it no question, I'm a simple minded person, I can enjoy repetitive things like driving the same car around a the same track 200 laps to get the fastest time ;) But it's not the individual case I was wondering about. Anyway, I'm going to drop this now and wait for the preorder to open :thumbsup:
osen
Posts: 7
Joined: 16 Aug 2011, 18:04

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by osen »

zarexz wrote:I must really have a completely different perception of the value of money I guess. 20 bucks is even less then peanuts. For me, a small two hours work. For the avarage smoker about 3 days worth of smoking. A paperboy could earn that in a week.... About 4 weeks saving avarage allowens? Doing the dishes for your parrents? Wash your uncle's car? C'mon guys, get over it! :teub:
Well, you could reason like that over anything. What if a bottle of soda was 10 bucks? Would you pay that? Anyway, €20 is about $30, and if there would be 7 environments like in TM1 for €20 each, that would be over 200 US dollars. What's a normal game in the US, about $60? That's quite the difference. Anyway, I'll shut up now :D
cyreb7
Posts: 3
Joined: 30 Jun 2010, 20:47

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by cyreb7 »

I was lurking in this thread and I totally missed that the pre-order is up!!!
User avatar
Trackmaniack
Posts: 2096
Joined: 16 Jun 2010, 16:16
Location: Iowa City, IA
Contact:

Re: So...Who's getting the Preorder Beta Thing?

Post by Trackmaniack »

osen wrote:
zarexz wrote:I must really have a completely different perception of the value of money I guess. 20 bucks is even less then peanuts. For me, a small two hours work. For the avarage smoker about 3 days worth of smoking. A paperboy could earn that in a week.... About 4 weeks saving avarage allowens? Doing the dishes for your parrents? Wash your uncle's car? C'mon guys, get over it! :teub:
Well, you could reason like that over anything. What if a bottle of soda was 10 bucks? Would you pay that? Anyway, €20 is about $30, and if there would be 7 environments like in TM1 for €20 each, that would be over 200 US dollars. What's a normal game in the US, about $60? That's quite the difference. Anyway, I'll shut up now :D
I see your point, and I have no desire to dredge up old arguments again, but I feel the need to say you seem to be missing a point, here. Ths point in question is that Maniaplanet is not "one game, broken up into 9 (or 15, if Hylis' dream is to be realized) smaller titles, but 9 (or 15) complete games. That all can interact with each other together, or separately. You can purchase Canyon, and then not purchase Valley. That's like buying Island, but not Coast (cuz you don't like it or whatever). And yes, while on mix-map servers, the players that don't have Valley, again as an example, will be kicked, I'm quite sure there will be dedicated one-envi only servers. And two envi servers (Canyon/Storm). Or something like that. The community (and Nadeo) always find a way to make things work out for the players. :)
WIP
Post Reply

Return to “Trackmania 2”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests